Editor’s Note: This is the fifth article in our series called “I Can’t Believe I Did That,” where pilots ‘fess up about mistakes they’ve made but lived to tell about. If you have a story to tell, email us at: [email protected]
Two Souls above Jamestown
By: Bob Tackett
December 4, 1995, a little over a year since earning our instrument ratings, my dad and I found ourselves flying in dark clouds in our club’s Grumman Tiger. We had departed Cleveland Cuyahoga County airport in Ohio and were now en route to Dunkirk in upstate New York where we would make a brief stop then fly on to Jamestown, New York for lunch. I was the pilot-in-command for the flight but with only 11 hours of actual instrument time, it was comforting to have another instrument-rated pilot with me, even if he was also low-time.
The forecast was for widespread cloud layers and predominately IFR conditions along our route.
Icing hadn’t been mentioned in the preflight briefing I received within 20 minutes of our departure, but for some reason, my dad commented that he’d like to experience aircraft icing sometime. Well, okay, I thought, as long as it’s not this time on this flight.
We were cleared for 7,000 and climbing in the clouds when suddenly something started banging on the airplane from outside and aft of where we were sitting. About the same time, I noticed that the needle on the number two VOR display wasn’t even close to being centered like the needle was on the number one display, even though both were set to the same radio frequency and on the same inbound radial.
Could the external antenna have come loose?
“Look out there,” my dad said, pointing a finger at the light ice buildup on the angular metal probe attached to the outside air temperature (OAT) gauge. He had gotten his wish.
Just then, we popped out of the clouds and were on top. The sunshine quickly melted the ice, the banging stopped, and the number two nav radio problem cleared. Erie Approach cleared us for the non-precision approach to Runway 24 at Dunkirk, a small uncontrolled airport with two runways and a VOR on the field. We landed, I pulled on the radio antennas to make sure they were secure, got an updated weather briefing, filed IFR to Jamestown, and then we took off once more into the wild dark-gray yonder.
Jamestown is a small uncontrolled airport with a restaurant on the field. Although only about 19 nautical miles from Dunkirk as the crow flies, to get to Jamestown from Dunkirk flying IFR, we had to first fly 18 miles from Dunkirk on Victor 265 to KRAUS intersection. A turn to 246 degrees would then line us up on the 6 ½ mile ILS approach for Runway 25.
The briefing in Dunkirk hadn’t mentioned icing on our route but the Tiger’s OAT probe was already starting to pick up ice again as we reached our assigned altitude, immersed in a sea of dark gray.
“Erie Approach, Grumman Tiger 74451. We’re level at 5,000 and picking up ice in the clouds.”
“Roger. 74451 climb to 6,000,” the young male voice instructed. “That should put you on top.”
“451, climbing to six,” I replied.
I leveled out at 6,000, still surrounded by darkness.
“Erie Approach, 451 is level at six, still in the clouds and picking up ice.”
“Understood 74451. You are cleared to climb to 7,000.”
“451 is out of six for seven.”
I pushed the throttle full forward and pulled back on the yoke.
The airplane was feeling sluggish now. I had pulled the carburetor heat full on, hoping the engine wouldn’t quit from ice blockage. The heat would account for a slight decrease in engine power but not the poor climb rate we were experiencing now. Even with full throttle, the Tiger could only make it to 6,700 feet. Now, I struggled to keep us from descending.
“Erie Approach, 451 is at 6,700, still in the clouds, still picking up ice, and unable to climb further.”
If only we could get somewhere warm to melt this crap, I thought. Lake Erie was nearby and the waters were still open. If I could get us into the warmer-than-freezing air just above the lake, maybe enough ice would melt so we could fly to the closest airport and land.
“Erie, 451 would like vectors to Lake Erie before the aircraft becomes unflyable.”
“451, Erie Approach. Instead of vectors to the lake, I can give you a vector that will take you out of the cloud mass.”
“451 will take whatever will get us out of the ice the quickest,” I radioed back. “I don’t know how much longer the airplane will be flyable.”
I accepted a northeast heading, made a slow coordinated turn, then Erie called back with a question.
“Grumman 74451, Erie Approach. How many souls on board?”
I had been in total control of my thoughts and actions right up until the moment he asked the question. Now, my mind raced through the implications. I saw tomorrow’s headline, a picture of a smashed airplane, and the story about how the air traffic controller had confirmed that there were just two people in the airplane at the time of the fatal crash.
I looked over at my dad. He looked back at me. Then we both laughed!
We’d been in dire situations before, he in the Navy and me in the fire department. I guess after facing the possibility of death a few times and coming out alive, you tend to get cocky. Why not gloat when you make it? We knew there would come a time when death would win. You can’t change that. We simply chose to make death powerless over how we live by laughing when it stared at us from the darkness at 6,700 feet.
I held up my hand to tell my dad to stop laughing for a minute so I could sound serious on the radio then thumbed the transmit button on the yoke.
“Uh, Erie, 451 has two souls on board.”
A few minutes later, I keyed the mic again.
“Erie Approach, how much longer at this heading should 451 expect to be out of the clouds?”
The radio was quiet for too long before the reply.
“You should have been out by now 451. Standby.”
I’m pretty sure at this point the controller’s supervisor took charge because we received a new vector that reversed our course. As it turned out, the initial vector ATC had given us had been driving us deeper into the mess.
I made the 180 degree turn and quit struggling to keep altitude after being cleared to descend to 4,000. Within minutes, a partly cloudy sky with the sun looming large on the western horizon welcomed us. The Tiger still had a load of ice on the airframe, so I couldn’t relax just yet. The added weight and degraded flight surfaces meant I still had to focus on flying the airplane and making the approach and landing at Jamestown.
I intercepted the glideslope on the ILS for Runway 25 feeling the effects of 30-knot winds and noticed that none of the ice we had accumulated was breaking off or melting. Luckily, ice hadn’t reduced forward visibility through the canopy and I could see the runway ahead. If I could keep the airspeed higher than normal for the approach and leave the flaps alone, I figured we had a pretty good chance at not crashing short of the runway.
Soon, a large white number 25 slid under the Tiger’s belly and I heard the chirp-chirp of rubber tires kissing the asphalt. The landing had become a white-knuckled non-event. I taxied to the ramp by the restaurant and shut down the engine. My dad and I slid the canopy back and stepped out to get a good look at the Tiger.
An inch of ice on the OAT probe and at the wing roots, in addition to a five-eighths inch buildup on the leading edge of both wings and on the antennas, still refused to melt. We opted to walk to the airport terminal and have a hot lunch in hopes of coming back afterward and finding the ice gone.
Although there was still some ice on the aircraft after we finished our meal, my dad and I were able to clean off what little that remained and then enjoy an ice-free flight back to our home base.
The following are my confessions.
I should have told ATC and the flight briefer (when we were on the ground at Dunkirk), about picking up ice the first time. Because it had been minimal and had melted as soon as we got on top, I didn’t think it was important at the time. I was wrong. If I’d given the icing report, then other pilots would have also been warned when getting their briefing.
Even though it wasn’t mentioned in the briefing, after picking up ice en route to Dunkirk, I should have been wary of ice on the flight to Jamestown and either waited on the ground for the clouds to pass or stay out of them if continuing the flight.
I should have declared an emergency as soon as I had a problem with keeping the aircraft at altitude.
Finally, I should have had better positional awareness. Instead of blindly following ATC deeper into the clouds, I should have known where to expect the nearest VFR conditions.
William (Bob) Tackett is a retired firefighter/paramedic, the author of General Aviation Firefighting for Structural Firefighters, and currently teaches part-time for the National Fire Academy and Lakeland Community College. He and his dad began their flight training together and helped each other along as they earned their private pilot certificates and instrument ratings. Bob belongs to the Galion Pilots Group, AOPA, EAA, and is currently part owner of a Cessna 150, 172, and 182 as a member of Galion Air in Ohio.
- Two men, a tropical storm and a hurricane fly into the sunshine state - January 23, 2017
- An Oshkosh rookie no more - August 10, 2016
- My adventure: a long day of flying in a 172 - August 22, 2014
i always tell pilots, “welcome to NY”, who fly in from other parts of the country. The weather we experience up here in western NY is very dinamic to say the least. I fly out of KROC as a IFR/Commercial rated student…out of Jamestown Community College. The short trip from Dunkirk can be a challenge in IFR conditions from one minute to the next. reporting any icing is super important. I turned around heading into JHW once after hearing of icing conditions and i was only 20 NM out. Up here, we don’t play games with ice unless the aircraft is properly equipped and the forcast, PIREPS and controllers all agree that GA aircraft can safetly make their trip. Glad the outcome was favorible….many are not so lucky
Very thorough self-diagnosis on that one, and to Patrick’s comment, here in the NE, we get nasty stuff a lot and FIKI or at least inadvertent anti-ice protection to me is a must for much of the year, because the lake effect surprises can be dangerous.
Very well put, Bob.
I’m glad the outcome was good. I’m early enough in my flying endeavor that I haven’t encountered ice yet. This article is a good warning for what to expect and what to do.
The two most important take-away points for me was: 1. Know where to fly to get out of clouds/ice before leaving the runway. 2. Don’t be a passive pilot that abdicates responsibility for safety of the flight to ATC. Pilot and ATC part of a team with the pilot having final authority for flight safety.