As a radar technician with the US Air Force in the 1970s, I spent many hours in the cockpit of the Air Force’s premier fighter at that time, the powerful McDonnell-Douglas F-4E. I loved being around and working on aircraft and often imagined what it would be like to fly an aircraft and be the pilot in command.
My love of aviation was born from the stories my father recounted to me from his experiences as an aviation machinist’s mate and plane captain with the Navy in WWII. While never a pilot himself, he loved working on aircraft and had many fond memories of flights he had taken on many of the aircraft he had helped maintain. Dad’s keen interest in aviation kindled a spark in me and I joined the Air Force to work on aircraft as he had. Soon after completing my enlistment, I started flight training to further my dream of flight. Soon after starting I found myself at the controls of the legendary Cessna 150.
I began my flight training at Smoky Mountain Aero, a small FBO and flight school located on McGhee-Tyson Airport (TYS) in Knoxville, Tennessee. TYS was a busy controlled airport handling a mix of commercial, military, business, and private air traffic. Smoky Mountain Aero was a Cessna Flight School and I was soon sporting a large red Cessna satchel filled with all the tools needed to complete ground school and flight training for the private pilot certificate. My enthusiastic instructor soon had me in the left seat, clumsily trying to duplicate his smooth flying. My first thoughts were that this was more difficult than I thought it would be. Those Air Force pilots had made it look so easy.
Following the curriculum, I was soon introduced to simple maneuvers including turns, slow flight, takeoffs and landings, maintaining heading, and generally keeping the aircraft under proper control. After several hours of instruction I was introduced to stalls and their recovery. From there we progressed to departure stalls, which demanded more skill at maintaining proper coordination of the controls, especially the rudder. We practiced these over and over and while I got through the exercise successfully, I honestly never felt comfortable doing them. I never told my instructor about my unease with departure stalls. This was a decision that I would soon come to regret.
Solo day finally arrived. I had accumulated around 15 hours of instruction and my instructor thought I could successfully fly the pattern of McGhee-Tyson Airport. I made three circuits around the pattern, properly communicating with the tower and making two touch-and-gos and a full stop with no problems. My confidence level was stratospheric. After solo, there was more training in slow flight, stalls and steep turns, along with preparations for a short cross country with the instructor. However, my instructor also released me for solo practice on my own with one condition: hold off practicing stalls solo until I had more experience and additional dual instruction.
My first solo practice flight was routine and uneventful. I was able to get the airplane out of the parking area, taxi to the runway, take off, and then navigate to the practice area with no problems. After practicing a few simple maneuvers and tasks for 30 minutes, I returned to the airport and landed safely. Again, my self confidence soared.
My next solo practice flight started off much like the first one. I flew to the practice area while climbing to the maneuvering altitude of 1500 feet AGL, practiced a few simple maneuvers and decided I could do more. Feeling confident, I decided to move on to more complex tasks. After practicing slow flight for a few minutes, I tried a few power-off stalls. Completing those successfully and returning to 1500 feet AGL, I felt that I could handle a departure stall with no problem. Despite the warning from my instructor and still being uncomfortable with the maneuver, I decided to proceed.
Configuring the aircraft for takeoff and slowing the 150 to its lift-off speed of 55 mph, I pulled the yoke back for a straight ahead climb and applied full takeoff power. This is where things did not go as planned. With only one aboard, everything felt different and very rushed. Due to my inexperience, coordination in the climb was very poor and I overlooked the fact that the ball in the turn coordinator was deflected far to the right, indicating the need for more right rudder than I was applying.
The stall came quickly and, to my senses, violently. The left wing dropped quickly, followed by the nose. Unknown to me, I was experiencing the beginning of an incipient spin. All I could see was the ground filling the windshield and rotation beginning to the left. Not really knowing what I was doing, I released back pressure, reduced power, and continued to hold the ailerons in the neutral position. Thanks to the good design of the Cessna, it quickly returned to near normal flight. Shakily, I returned to the airport and landed, wondering if I had what it took to be a pilot and if this may be my last flight.
I confessed what had happened to my flight instructor. Patiently, he explained why it happened and what I had done wrong to cause the problem. But, he also told me I had done well to have made sure I was at a proper altitude to perform the maneuver. Continuing his post flight analysis, he thought that while I had not quite performed the spin recovery procedure correctly, the fact that I had held the ailerons in a neutral position, reduced power, and most likely still had some right rudder applied, helped in the recovery. The design of the 150 as a trainer also contributed to the recovery before the spin fully developed.
On our next flight, we practiced the departure stall while he walked me through it, explaining each step in detail and why it was important. He also explained spins and the importance of vigilance to avoid them, especially at low altitudes.
Years later, as a CFI myself, I often look back on that experience with disbelief, while thankful of my good luck. The potential for much a more serious outcome was very real. I was lucky that I was at a good altitude to recover and the Cessna C 150 was a very forgiving trainer. Now, when demonstrating stalls as a CFI, I always think back to that experience and make sure the student understands the importance of proper maneuvering altitude and proper coordinated control, as well as the dangers of overconfidence.
Editor’s Note: This article is from our series called “I Can’t Believe I Did That,” where pilots ‘fess up about mistakes they’ve made but lived to tell about. If you have a story to tell, email us at: [email protected].
- Overconfident and under-coordinated - May 20, 2021
I’m glad someone else had the same experience with a solo departure stall that I had many years ago and possessed the wherewithal to extricate himself from it safely. The one difference between you and me is that you remember just what you did to recover. I only remember entering the stall from a heading of north, and then next thing I remember is flying straight and level to the south. Boom; that’s it.
It is important that the instructor lets the students know that they can and should say there is something they are not comfortable or sure about doing and that the student tells the instructor they are not comfortable or sure about something they are doing…….
Our flying club owns a Piper Dakota (PA 28-235). I learned to fly before I learned to drive as a teen (Cessna 150s), and now as an old fart I am regressing to teenhood once again and re-learning to fly despite a medical condition that precludes receiving a medical certificate. So I fly with a CFI…it’s fine.
The Dakota moves with alacrity even with a big guy like me in the left seat. Power-on stalls are nothing short of jaw-dropping, and are practiced at less than full power because … well, we did a full-power & RPM approach to a departure stall once and only once because my God I swear we were at about 60 degrees pitch-up or more and the darn thing just barely started to buffet before we lowered the nose. I was told that to do more or force a full stall risked sliding backward (if I remember correctly) and a hammerhead stall, two things that sounded much too acrobatic (and dangerous) for our Dakota. (“Spins prohibited.”)
Yes, I know the Dakota isn’t a “student plane” but since I have recent experience in other craft, including 172s, it’s really just for fun and my own edification. That I can actually fly it reasonably well is icing on the cake.
I thought I was reading my own student pilot story 1980. I also became a CFI and stress rudder use.
I did try same thing over the coast of Maine while training for my private license. 1500’ and lack of coordination. I’m sure the sunbathers on the beach got quite a show that day. I recovered at 500’ and flew myself back to the airport. I didn’t tell anyone for years and became quite proficient in steep turns in the practice area.
Now many years and a few thousand flight hours later I’m much more much more confident in my flying skills and much more coordinated when practicing stalls.
I can tell you how it could have turned out. I picked up a new, to me, post solo student for a currency ride. I could tell by the taxi manners out to the runway that he was way overconfident for his experience level. So out in the practice area, in the a departure stall to the left, I lightly tapped the right rudder and the airplane broke over the top into a nicely developed spin. He pulled the wheel full aft and started rolling it (the wheel) full left and right. After two turns, he looks over at me and yells, “Well, what are you going to do to save us now?”. We spent the rest of the session practicing spin recoveries.
I learnt to fly at Juan Air in Victoria BC, Canada. When practicing slow flight and stalls, my instructor always reminded me to apply a little bit of right rudder to stop the aircraft yawing left. All that was taken care of.
One dat at the end of few lessons, he asked me to show a power off stall and recovery. I had the power off and raised the nose up gently waiting for the stall horn. Just then when the horn sounded, the left wing dropped and my aircraft nose pointed to the ground and spinning left. My instructor said calmly “I have controls”. He did something and we were straight and level. He explained what happens if you do not control the left yaw. He had intentionally kicked the left rudder to put the aircraft into a spin. I was not aware. That was my introduction to spin and he told me we would be practicing tomorrow. I was scared at first but later I did them all by myself. I became good at it. We had to demonstrate entry and recovery for PPL and CPL check-rides.
Happy flying !
Wonderful learning story. You have hit on the #1 cause of fatal loss of control accidents. It is not intuitive, as Suresh’s student illustrated, that pushing forward to reduce angle of attack (AOA) is the right recovery procedure when the ground is filling the windscreen and rushing up at you. Great job, and thanks for sharing!
Actually the spin on short final to landing is one of the major killers in GA. Gotta be really careful.